The drums of war were beating a terrifying tune as word spread of the adoption of the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776 by the Second Continental Congress at the Pennsylvania State House. An already divided young nation was facing the ominous risk of a failed revolution. If the revolution were to fail, their lives and fortunes would be at stake. On July 9, 1776, the first guns were fired by revolutionaries at British troops and loyalists at the Battle of Cricket Hill. While compared to the Battle of Brooklyn August 27, 1776, it was a minor skirmish. Historically, it marked the end of the rule of the last British royal governor of Virginia, John Murray, 4th Earl of Dunmore.
Scottish born Lord Dunmore was appointed governor of the Colony of Virginia by Britain’s King George III on September 21, 1771. It was a post he did not ask for, nor did he want. In fact, he asked British King George III to relieve him of the position, to which a very annoyed King George III said, “to fit yourself with all convenient speed and repair to our said colony of Virginia”. There was no choice for Dunmore. While at first Lord Dunmore disliked the Colony of Virginia, he soon became enamored by it. In fact, he began a cordial relationship with George Washington. Lord Dunmore bought land, acquired enslaved people and dreamed of owning extensive property to the west, as did George Washington. Lord Dunmore and Washington had a lot in common and dined together frequently.
Lord Dunmore enjoyed the good life and was interested in improving the colony he now called his home. His three sons attended the College of William and Mary. Lord Dunmore knew Thomas Jefferson and shared a keen interest in fine horses with him. Dunmore was the first person to ask Thomas Jefferson to design an architectural addition for the College of William and Mary. By the spring 1773, they had drifted apart.
Jefferson and his coterie drew up a resolution imploring God to avert the “destruction of our civil rights, and the evils of civil war.” On the morning of “dissolution day” May 26, 1774, following breakfast with Colonel Washington, Lord Dunmore dissolved the House of Burgesses. Lord Dunmore called for a meeting of the sixty-odd members of the House of Burgesses and declared, “I have in my hand a paper published by order of your House conceived in such term as to reflect highly upon his Majesty and the Parliament of Great Britain; which makes it necessary for me to dissolve you; and you are dissolved accordingly.” This action was taken after the colonial assembly set aside June 1, 1774, as a day of fasting and prayer to protest the British Parliament’s closure of Boston Harbor. The cordial relationship between George Washington and Lord Dunmore ended when it became apparent that Lord Dunmore was fearful of the growing revolutionary sentiment after the Boston Tea Party.
Dunmore’s plans of obtaining extensive land to the west were shattered when John Connally, encouraged by Lord Dunmore, slaughtered several Mingo Indian people on January 1, 1774. The incident became known as the Yellow Creek massacre. In that same year, Lord Dunmore personally led an expedition called Lord Dunmore’s War against the Indians in Western Virginia. In 1775, Lord Dunmore ordered the gunpowder removed from the magazine in Williamsburg. This action enraged the citizenry. Fearful of his growing unpopularity, Lord Dunmore isolated himself in the Governor’s Palace in Williamsburg. Another of Lord Dunmore’s most controversial actions involved issuing a
proclamation on November of 1775 to free all the slaves and indentured servants of rebellious colonists. It offered freedom to enslaved people and indentured servants, provided they agree to bear arms for the British Crown.
In early January of 1776, Lord Dunmore ordered the British ships to bombard Norfolk, Virginia. When the smoke cleared, the city of Norfolk was burnt to the ground, although there were disputes as to who actually burned the majority of the city, Dunmore’s forces or the Patriots themselves.
Like the smell of gunpowder on a battlefield, war fever was in the air in May 1776. Lord Dunmore was no longer in his mansion in Williamsburg. For months, he had been living aboard British ships. Lord Dunmore’s fleet of about British 82 ships ran up the Chesapeake Bay and set anchor in the waters of Milford Haven off the shore of Gwynn’s Island, in what is now present-day Mathews County. Soon after Lord Dunmore’s ship and many more ships of his fleet arrived, some of the Dunmore’s crews were sent ashore to obtain water, provisions, and build entrenchments. A hundred British soldiers of the 14th Regiment, a hundred marines, a hundred and fifty volunteers from Norfolk, fifty seamen, and about three hundred African-Americans were ultimately stationed at various points on the island. Among Dunmore’s troops were the Ethiopian Regiment, formerly enslaved and indentured people whose ranks were devastated by small pox and other fatal diseases. Lord Dunmore mockingly called the local colonial militiamen “crickets on a hill”, claiming they would easily be smashed like insects.
The Patriots’ weakness was two-fold – the power of the British warships with their cannons and the lack of Patriot naval vessels to maneuver across the water to engage Lord Dunmore’s forces. The Patriots besieged Dunmore’s forces from their position on the mainland with relentless musket fire for several weeks while they built earthworks for two cannon batteries. By July 9th, the Patriots had completed their cannon batteries, which included two eighteen-pound cannons in the upper battery (on what is present-day U S Coast Guard Station Milford Haven) and several smaller cannons in the lower battery (on what is present-day Morningstar Marinas). At dawn and at low tide on July 9th, General Andrew Lewis opened fire on Lord Dunmore’s fleet. It was reported that an 18-pound cannonball smashed a large hole in Lord Dunmore’s cabin, destroyed his fine China dishes and slightly wounded him. A second shot hit Dunmore’s sailing master, cutting him in half.
This skirmish between Lord Dunmore’s forces and the colonists became known as the Battle of Cricket Hill. It is also known as the Battle of Gwynn’s Island. The battle marked the end of Lord Dunmore’s rein over the Colony of Virginia. Defeated and disgraced in Virginia, he fled to England where, ironically, he was hailed as a hero. Unaware of the British defeat at Yorktown, Lord Dunmore vowed to return to America.
Peter Jennings Wrike, highly accomplished historian and author of the book The Governors’ Island, (The Gwynn’s Island Museum, page 115) wrote; “Dunmore suffered not only from the lack of coherent strategy but from his own personal arrogance. Dunmore displayed only contempt for the patriots and often discounted their strength and abilities. His methods and tactics frequently polarized those he encountered. His arrogant attitude toward colonists and misuse of power antagonized them. Dunmore possessed considerable disdain for the colonists much like the attitudes of Clinton, Burgoyne, Howe, and other British commanders who frequently displayed a similar arrogance. The strategy and tactic Dunmore employed to intimidate and subdue Virginia produced the opposite effect. The harder Dunmore tried to control he Virginians, the more they sought freedom. The harder Dunmore attempted to reimpose royal authority; the more Virginians worked to develop their own government.”
The Battle of Cricket Hill is celebrated annually in mid-July at the battle site. In celebration of the 250th anniversary of the Battle of Cricket Hill in 2026, the National Society Sons of the American Revolution and the National Society Daughters of the American Revolution partnered with the Mathews County VA250 Committee to host a multi-day celebration of the battle. The colorful event drew people from all over the state. The purpose was to bring the Revolutionary War era to life through immersive reenactments, living history encampments, colonial demonstrations, historic vessels, and family-friendly educational experiences honoring one of Virginia’s important Revolutionary War engagements. Visitors had the opportunity to explore authentic military camps where Revolutionary War reenactors and their camp followers recreated daily colonial life. Throughout the weekend, guests interacted with soldiers, sailors, tradespeople, and interpreters while learning about the events surrounding the Battle of Cricket Hill and the defense of Virginia’s waterways in 1776. One of the featured attractions was the replica eighteenth century schooner Luna, docked at The Hatchery Oyster Eatery docks alongside additional colonial watercraft. Live battle reenactments were conducted all weekend, featuring British forces on Gwynn’s Island and Patriot troops positioned across the mainland at Morningstar Marinas. The reenactments included dramatic cannon, mortar and musket demonstrations as reenactors recreated the sounds and atmosphere of the historic conflict.
For details about this yearly event visit virginiasar.org/calendar.


